UK tribunal says government must confirm Apple encryption order
Britain's Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on Thursday that the government has not shown that acknowledging a secret order to Apple would harm national security, Reuters reported.

The tribunal said the Home Office must confirm in the proceedings that it issued Apple a technical capability notice, which requires the company to be able to bypass encryption to reach customer data. The ruling does not decide whether the order is lawful.
The government had argued that confirming the notice would "provide material assistance to hostile actors". The tribunal disagreed, saying the government "has not established that it would be damaging to national security to reveal in these proceedings" that the notice exists. According to heise online, it noted that the order had already been widely reported and discussed by senior US officials.
Apple, together with the groups Privacy International and Liberty, challenged the government's "neither confirm nor deny" stance. Apple says it has not complied with the order and disputes it on several grounds, including that UK law does not allow the government to dictate a company's security features. How much of the notice can be disclosed will be decided at later hearings, some of them closed.
A government spokesperson said the notice "simply requires that they maintain the ability" to help police and intelligence agencies, and that decisions on public safety must be made by elected governments, "not in the boardrooms of technology companies". Liberty director Akiko Hart called the ruling "a victory for transparency".
A first notice issued in January 2025 covered encrypted cloud backups of both US and UK users and was dropped after talks with the Trump administration, Reuters reported. A second notice, from July 2025, applies only to UK customers. A full hearing on the legality of the order is expected in 2027.



