EnglishРусский中文EspañolDeutsch
Independent world news

Fed rate hike in December: how far will Kevin Warsh's Fed go?

A December Fed rate hike now looks all but settled; the real fight is over its size and over what follows in 2027. Here is what the hawks, the doves and the White House are arguing, and which data will decide it.

Fed rate hike in December: how far will Kevin Warsh's Fed go?
Photo: The White House / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

On November 18th the Federal Reserve published the minutes of its October meeting, and one line did most of the work. Almost all officials, the document said, judged that further rate increases "would likely be appropriate". A couple went further: if inflation data disappointed, a move bigger than a quarter of a percentage point could be considered at the next meeting, on December 8th and 9th. For a generation of borrowers who assumed the era of Fed rate hikes had ended in 2023, the question in Washington is no longer whether the central bank tightens again, but by how much.

Futures markets have made up their minds about the first part. After Governor Christopher Waller repeated on CNBC on November 18th that a half-point increase should be on the table, CME FedWatch data put the probability of a quarter-point rise in December at 92.7% and of a half-point move at 7.3%, up from 3.1% a day earlier. The federal funds rate sits at 3.75% to 4%, where it has been since September 16th, when the Fed under its new chairman, Kevin Warsh, raised rates for the first time since July 2023.

Why the Fed rate hike debate matters now

The inflation numbers explain the urgency. Fed staff estimated that the personal consumption expenditures (PCE) price index, the Fed's preferred gauge, rose 3.6% in the 12 months to September, with core PCE, which excludes food and energy, at 3.1%. Consumer prices rose 0.4% in October after 0.6% in September, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics; core prices rose 0.3%. There is no official annual CPI rate for October, because last year's government shutdown stopped data collection, but Gregory Daco, chief economist at EY-Parthenon, estimates headline inflation at about 4.1%. Petrol was 37.4% dearer than a year earlier. By the New York Times's count, inflation has now been above the Fed's 2% target for nearly six years.

The labour market gives the Fed little reason to hold back. Employers added 165,000 jobs in October and unemployment slipped to 4.1%. Bond markets have already done some of the tightening: the yield on the ten-year Treasury note climbed to 5.143% on November 13th, after touching 5.174% intraday, according to CNBC. Mortgage Daily put the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate at 7.25% in the week of November 16th. A stronger dollar pushed gold below $3,800 an ounce on November 18th for the first time in 14 months.

The hawks: "You may have to shock people"

Mr Waller is the loudest voice for speed. On November 10th, speaking in London, he set a public test: if core CPI for October rose 0.3% or more, "I believe a 50-basis-point hike in the policy rate should be considered at the December meeting." The number came in at exactly 0.3%. Eight days later he told CNBC that the Fed must either deliver half a point in December or clearly signal another increase in January. "If you really want to bring inflation down, you have to be more aggressive," he said. "You may have to shock people."

He is not alone in wanting more, even if he is alone in wanting it at once. Alberto Musalem, president of the St Louis Fed, told a central-bank conference in Buenos Aires on November 17th that "the economy will likely require several interest rate increases before the spring of 2027 to achieve price stability". His argument is about timing: "Moving sooner, while inflation expectations are anchored, has a better chance of succeeding." Mr Musalem does not vote this year. Two people who do, Governor Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack of the Cleveland Fed, dissented in October because they wanted a quarter-point rise then rather than in December. Austan Goolsbee of the Chicago Fed has argued that price pressures are building well beyond what high oil prices can explain, and Mary Daly of the San Francisco Fed has called a hike likely.

The private-sector economists who track the details are mostly on the hawks' side of the argument, if not on Mr Waller's side of the size question. "This hotter and broader inflation report likely seals the deal for a Fed rate hike in December," Mr Daco wrote after the October CPI release, adding that a half-point move "should not be discounted". Leslie Preston, a senior economist at TD Economics, found that services inflation excluding housing, a measure Fed officials watch closely, was running at an annualised 5.7% over three months. "Inflation pressures are fairly broad-based across categories, and most importantly show little sign of cooling," she wrote.

The case for patience inside the Fed

John Williams, president of the New York Fed and vice-chairman of the rate-setting committee, offered the counterweight a day before the minutes appeared. At an Axios event in New York on November 17th he said inflation still needed work but that conditions did not call for a dramatic move, that price pressures were not broadening and that the effect of tariffs was largely behind the economy. In October he had said one more increase might be appropriate, but that he did not expect to need further rises after that. That is a materially different path from Mr Musalem's.

Mr Warsh himself has been careful with words. He described the September increase not as tightening but as removing "a dose of accommodation". In early November he said financial conditions had tightened, but he was "unwilling and unable to call them tight", and stressed that the Fed's aim was not "to throw sand in the gears of the economy and throw people out of work". The Fed's own staff expect inflation to step down sharply next year and to be about 2% in 2028. If they are right, the case for a big December move weakens.

An energy shock, or something broader?

Beneath the disagreement over basis points lies a deeper one about diagnosis. Inflation surged after the American and Israeli strikes on Iran in February and the disruption of shipping through the Strait of Hormuz. The orthodox textbook says central banks should look through supply shocks, because raising rates cannot conjure up more oil.

That is the Treasury's position. "I think the Fed should understand that this is an energy supply shock," Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNBC on November 13th. "The Fed's supposed to look into the future, not look in the rearview mirror." His evidence is that fuel is getting cheaper: the national average price of petrol was $3.87 a gallon, down from $4.34 a month earlier, though still far above the $2.98 of February 28th. Physical Brent crude has fallen from about $136 a barrel to around $92 in six weeks. In September Kevin Hassett, director of the White House National Economic Council, argued that judged by three-month trends inflation was close to 2% and that there was "not a lot of room to go up from here".

The hawks answer that the shock has leaked out of energy. The October minutes record that "the vast majority" of officials saw high energy prices still feeding current inflation, but core prices rose another 0.3% in October, producer prices were up 7% on a year earlier in the latest report, the biggest gain since 2022, and the services measure Ms Preston tracks is accelerating. Analysts who remember the 1970s also note that the Fed's hikes into the oil shocks of 1973-74 and 1979-82 were followed by recessions. The doves treat that history as a warning against overreaction; the hawks read it as proof of what happens when a central bank lets inflation expectations slip.

The AI wildcard

The October minutes added a new character to the story: the artificial-intelligence investment boom. Many officials called the buildout of data centres and chips "a material source of inflation risk". They noted that demand for AI-related products "was continuing to strain supply" and that price pressure was spreading beyond industries directly touched by construction. Mr Williams, the most dovish senior voice, also flagged AI as a likely persistent source of inflation.

The same pages carry a financial-stability warning. Most participants observed that "AI-related debt had grown rapidly", much of it through what the minutes call complex and opaque structures, and staff warned that off-balance-sheet lease commitments and circular financing among AI firms could magnify losses if the investments fail to pay off. That cuts both ways for the rate path. Hot AI spending argues for higher rates; a sudden AI bust would argue for cuts. The record $107.3bn raised by Anthropic in its listing this week is a reminder of how much capital is still flowing into the sector.

A Fed under political pressure

All this unfolds against unusual political noise. Donald Trump picked Mr Warsh after years of demanding lower rates, and the White House called the September increase a "rather unfortunate decision". Mr Bessent insists he is not issuing orders: "I'm not going to tell the Fed what to do. I am going to say they should have an open mind."

Ms Cook, one of October's two hawkish dissenters, is simultaneously fighting a White House effort to fire her over mortgage-fraud allegations from 2021, which she denies; she has not been charged. A three-member committee that includes Mr Hassett is weighing whether there is cause. Her lawyer, Abbe Lowell, wrote that the panel "appears to be a facade designed to obscure a predetermined decision". In June the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that she could stay in her post while the case proceeds, noting that "the fact of independence but also the appearance of independence is key to the Federal Reserve's design". Investors will read any December dissent partly through this lens.

What Wall Street expects

The banks' forecasts cluster around a gradual path. Goldman Sachs expects a quarter-point increase in December and another in March 2027, taking the range to 4.25% to 4.5%, before cuts begin in November 2027. The New York Fed's survey of market participants, summarised in the minutes, showed a median expectation of one hike in December, another in March and a cut early in 2028. TD Economics says a December quarter-point rise is "fully priced in, and we agree". In September's projections, 16 of the 18 officials who submitted forecasts penciled in at least one more hike this year.

The Fed is not tightening alone. A Reuters poll of 71 economists in November found every one expecting the European Central Bank to raise its deposit rate to 2.75% in December, with more than a third seeing another move in early 2027. Simultaneous tightening on both sides of the Atlantic would add to pressure on emerging markets already squeezed by a strong dollar.

Scenarios: quarter point, half point or pause

The base case, held by futures markets and most banks, is a quarter-point rise to 4% to 4.25% with guidance that leaves a further move in early 2027 open. The question then becomes how explicitly the statement and Mr Warsh's press conference point to January or March, the condition Mr Waller has set for accepting the smaller step.

A half-point move is the hawkish tail. It would probably push Treasury yields and mortgage rates higher still and lift the dollar, and it would sharpen the clash with the White House. Most of the committee, judging by Mr Williams's remarks and the minutes, is not there yet.

A pause is the least likely outcome but not impossible. Mr Musalem himself calls a path with no further hikes "unlikely but still plausible". It would take soft October PCE figures, a weak November jobs report and a further fall in oil. The risks run in both directions: a renewed escalation around Hormuz, after the New York Times reported that Mr Trump is weighing new large-scale strikes on Iran, would push energy prices up again; a stumble in AI credit markets would pull the other way.

The calendar is short. The October PCE report arrives on November 25th; the November jobs report on December 4th. The committee meets on December 8th and 9th and publishes fresh projections, including the dot plot that will show how many officials expect to reach 4.25% or higher. Then comes an awkward twist: the November CPI is released on December 10th, the day after the decision, so the Fed will vote without it. The numbers to watch are whether monthly core inflation stays at or above Mr Waller's 0.3% threshold, whether the ten-year yield holds above 5%, and where Brent settles. The November PCE data, due on December 23rd, will show whether the Fed's next move in 2027 comes in January, in March or not at all.

This article is for information purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.

Fed rate hikeFed rate hike December 2026Federal Reserve interest rate forecastwill the Fed raise ratesFed half point hikeFOMC December meeting
More in Analysis