Independent analysis reproduces first black hole image
A team from Australia's national science agency CSIRO has independently reproduced the ring seen in the first image of a black hole, using a new method on the original Event Horizon Telescope data, according to a paper in Nature.

The four researchers, led by Samuel Lai, published their work in Nature on November 12 under the title "Independent interferometric observable confirms black hole shadow in M87*". Space.com reported the result on Friday.
Their technique, called GenDIReCT, was trained on ordinary photographs, so it had no prior knowledge of what a black hole should look like. Applied to the 2019 Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) data from the galaxy M87, it produced a ring almost identical in size and shape to the published EHT image.
EHT director Laurent Loinard said independent validation is at the heart of the scientific process.
The work has limits. It is a reanalysis of the same observations, not a new measurement made with a different instrument, and it does not image the event horizon directly or settle every question about the matter around the black hole.
The 2019 image of the supermassive black hole at the centre of M87 was the first of its kind. Space.com described the new result as supporting Einstein's general relativity, which predicted such objects.



